The High Cost of Judges: Reconsidering Judicial Pensions and Retirement in an Ageing Population

Monday, 5 March, 2012 - 16:30 to 18:00
New South Wales

Most Australian judges are remunerated through a package of benefits that includes salary during their years of judicial service, a judicial pension paid during their years of retirement, and a spousal pension paid to a judge's surviving spouse until the spouse's death. These non-contributory pensions are calculated as a proportion of the current judicial salary and their cost is rising rapidly. The unfunded liability at 30 June 2008 amounted to $586 million for federal judges alone, an increase of 23 per cent on the liability just three years earlier. Substantial increases in the life expectancy of Australians over the next 40-50 years will impose a very significant strain on the current system of judicial remuneration. This is because the judicial pension and the spousal pension will continue to rise substantially, while the period of judicial service remains constrained, at the lower end, by the need to acquire legal skills prior to judicial appointment; and at the upper end, by mandatory retirement of judges at 70 or 72 years.

This paper develops two metrics for measuring how the cost of judges changes under different assumptions about their age of appointment and retirement, and under different conditions about life expectancy of judges and their spouses. Three changes to the law will help to address the long term pressures of demographic change, namely: (a) increasing the maximum retirement age of judges; (b) increasing the minimum age at which judges qualify for the judicial pension; and (c) increasing the minimum years of service required to qualify for the judicial pension. Consistently with the core value of judicial independence, the second and third changes should be put in place for new judicial appointees only.

[The paper appears in (2011) 39 Federal Law Review 33 and will be distributed].


Speaker: Professor Brian Opeskin ( Macquarie University)

Commentators: Sir Anthony Mason AC KBE QC and Professor Michael Lavarch (Dean, Faculty of Law, Queensland Institute of Technology)

Chair: Professor Andrew Lynch (University of New south Wales)

Venue: Court 18A, Federal Court

Address: Queens Square, Sydney 2000 NSW


To download the NSW Program of Events 2012, please click here.



Why you should become a member

Seminars are restricted to members of AACL. Copies of papers are distributed to members in advance of the seminar by email. Members also receive other benefits such as newsletters and updates on constitutional law developments and events throughout the year.

The association was formed in 1998 as a forum for scholars and practitioners of constitutional law throughout Australia. It now has some 500 members throughout Australia and over 170 members in Sydney alone. More information on AACL may be found at


A person may become an ordinary member by applying for membership and paying the annual subscription. The annual subscription is $50.00 (concession $35.00). The membership year runs from July to June of each year. Membership is open to a person who is:

  • a judge, legal practitioner or government legal officer;
    • a current or former teacher of constitutional law or scholars engaged in research in the field of constitutional law or a related discipline;
    • a member of an association which is a member of the International Association of Constitutional Law or similar foreign associations as approved by the Council;
    • someone who is adjudged by the Council as having a sufficient interest, whether by reason of practical experience or occupation, in the field of constitutional law; or
    • A law student with written approval from a teacher of constitutional law.  

Application form and nomination

Under the current rules of the Association, an application for membership must be nominated and seconded by existing members. If you would like to join AACL, please:  

1.       Make an online payment for membership at (or follow the instructions to send a cheque to the National Secretariat)

2.       Download the AACL membership form at the same web address, and (despite the instruction on the website) send the form to the NSW Convenor (Christos Mantziaris) for nomination, seconding and placement on the AACL NSW email list. The NSW Convenor will then forward the form to the National Secretariat.

Please do not send me any cheques or cash to the NSW Convenor.

Membership and other enquiries

For all enquiries regarding membership or interstate activities please contact the National Secretariat, (tel 03-8344 1011). I hope you can join us for an exciting year ahead.